Was Light Yagami Destined to Lose in Death Note from the Start?

Death Note | Credits: AUS: Madman Entertainment/NA: Viz Media

Back in June 2007, the anime world saw (and lived) the conclusion of Death Note. The series did wrap up years ago, but even today, debates continue. And why not? Death Note set the bar real high with its suspense, complex character, and a plot that never let up. But let’s be real—did Light Yagami ever stand a chance of winning his deadly game, or was he doomed from the get-go?

Death Note ended with quite the bang! It split fans into two camps—those who saw the finale as a fitting end to Light’s twisted journey and those who couldn’t handle the bitter taste left behind. The anime and manga served up different endings, and these variations didn’t go unnoticed. While both concluded with Light’s death, the way his fate unfolded in each version? That’s where things got juicy.

Our genius high schooler Light Yagami found the Death Note—and embraced its lethal power. Obsessed with creating a utopia, he became a megalomaniac, ruthlessly eliminating anyone in his way—a chilling tale of power’s corrupting influence.

In both the manga and anime, Light’s downfall was inevitable, orchestrated by Near—L’s successor—and his team, who exposed Light as Kira. But here’s the twist: Light’s defeat played out differently on the page versus the screen. The manga gave us a groveling Light, begging Ryuk, his Shinigami sidekick, to save him, even blurting out, “I don’t want to die!” Poetic justice, right? The once-ruthless Kira, now pathetic and desperate, was forced to face his end when Ryuk coldly scribbled Light’s name in the Death Note.

The anime version, however, went for a more dramatic flair. Light didn’t beg for mercy—oh no, he doubled down. Trapped in the warehouse, he tried to justify his divine ambitions to Near and the Task Force. Even as the walls closed in, he clung to his delusions of godhood, desperately trying to scribble one last name in the Death Note. Matsuda, unable to hold back, shot him down, and a bleeding Light ran off into the night, only to collapse on a lonely staircase as Ryuk finally ended his life.

It’s all symbolic—Light stuck in limbo, neither Heaven nor Hell in sight. Ryuk’s act wasn’t a betrayal but a fulfillment of a promise. He’d told Light from the start, “When your time’s up, I’ll be the one to write your name down.” Whether you prefer the manga’s pitiful end or the anime’s more theatrical one, it’s clear Light’s fate was sealed.

The Death Note saga didn’t completely fade away with Light’s demise. Tsugumi Ohba and Takeshi Obata later expanded the universe with Death Note: Short Stories. One tale, The a-Kira Story, dropped jaws with its eerie Trump-like character bidding for the Death Note. Yep, politics crashed the manga party, giving fans a fresh twist in this dark universe.

Other stories dove into the past, revealing more about L’s upbringing in L: The Wammy’s House and his quirky daily routine in L: One Day. These chapters gave die-hard fans a deeper look at the detective who once went head-to-head with Light.

So, was Light Yagami truly destined to lose? Judging by both the manga and anime finales, it seems like the answer is a resounding yes. In the end, his obsession with power and control led him straight to his downfall.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *